Guest Commentator: John J. Taylor, Manager, Archer Public Affairs Pennsylvania and Eric Bugaile, Government Affairs Specialist, Archer @ArcherGreiner
How has the COVID-19 crisis impacted transportation funding and what steps can Pennsylvanians take to support the sector?
As if 2020 didn’t present us with enough pressing dilemmas to stress out about, there is another problem looming in the shadows: our transportation funding sources in Pennsylvania are severely diminished and going forward we all will need to play a role in solving the problem.
The Act 47/Act 89 mandated quarterly payments that the Pennsylvania Turnpike Commission makes to the Public Transportation Trust Fund (PTTF) will drop from $450 Million to just $50 Million annually in FY2022. Worse yet, Covid-19 has forced the Turnpike Commission to suspend their payments to PennDOT indefinitely. In addition, the continued reliance on the Pennsylvania Motor License Fund (MLF) to fund much of our State Police (PSP) budget coupled with the changing driving habits of Pennsylvania motorists will all contribute to a funding crisis that will no doubt have monumental negative effects on our ability to safely travel to work and school for years to come. Vehicle travel may be returning to levels seen prior to the Covid outbreak in the Philadelphia Region according to the Delaware Valley Regional Planning Commission but, perhaps that is at the expense of mass transit.
Covid-19 has reduced SEPTA ridership to about 30% of normal volume. As we approach the 2021-22 budget next June (yes, at this writing we don’t have a completed budget for this fiscal year yet) the PTTF will rely less on the Turnpike Commission for funding and more on proceeds from the Vehicle Sales Tax as provided by Act 89. This will create a large deficit in the General Fund at a time when the virus has wreaked havoc with the overall state budget.
The MLF, which is Pennsylvania’s primary source of funding for the building and repairing of our roads and bridges, continues to have dollars siphoned off to PSP funding despite legislation that weans the MLF of that obligation over a decade. The largest amount devoted to the PSP peaked at just over $820 Million in FY 2016-17. That number will continue to decline until FY 2028 when it will level off and be capped at $500 Million freeing up those funds for highway maintenance and construction.
The MLF is funded through our state fuel tax and motor license fees. With motorists driving less this year due to the pandemic, the revenues to the fund will take a hit. Adding to that shortfall is the gradual shift by some to electric vehicles whose drivers avoid payment into the Fund via the fuel tax.
With the rate of the fuel tax being one of the top rates in the nation, there is little appetite to look at increases from the public or our state elected officials. Alternative approaches have to be discussed. House Bills 2060 and 2061 seek to accelerate payments to the PTTF and to the MLF from the General Fund, but the Covid-related budget deficits make those possible obligations much more difficult.
Additional alternative solutions to be discussed include the tolling of our bridges; taxing electric vehicles; eliminating the gas tax in favor of tax per miles driven; and additional fees on everything from your driver’s license, car registrations and tires. Many of these were studied by House Republican Transportation Task Force, formed in 2019 and resulted in a 10-bill package. Much of this package will carry over into next year’s legislative session, no doubt.
Here is how you can help. Please make the issue of transportation funding is a priority in your discussions with the elected officials in your area. Help them realize that you think this crisis should be avoided with decisive action in the near future. Making sure that people can travel safely to their jobs and daily activities is good policy and good politics.
Finally, your voice is louder than you think. Utilize your local Chambers, your economic and redevelopment authorities and boards and your local newspapers to keep the discussion going. Let’s work from the ground up and keep Pennsylvania moving!
Learn how you can help grow Pennsylvania’s economic opportunities by getting involved with Grow PA at grow-pa.com.