In joint testimony with the African American Chamber of Commerce, Greater Philadelphia Hispanic Chamber of Commerce, Asian American Chamber of Commerce of Greater Philadelphia, and the Greater Northeast Philadelphia Chamber of Commerce, the Greater Philadelphia Chamber of Commerce (GPCC) testified before City Council to address businesses taxes in Philadelphia.
Below is testimony from GPCC’s Director of Public Policy, Joe Grace, on City Council Bill 130530, involving the Business Income & Receipts tax, formerly known as the Business Privilege tax.
TESTIMONY
Good morning Chairman Green and members of the Finance Committee. I am Joe Grace, Director of Public Policy for the Greater Philadelphia Chamber of Commerce (GPCC). Thank you for the opportunity to testify today on Bill 130530, which eliminates the net income portion of the Business Income & Receipts tax over the next five years, while quadrupling the gross receipts portion of the tax over the same time period.
I am joined at the hearing table today by representatives of the four other local Chambers of Commerce – the African-American Chamber of Commerce, the Greater Philadelphia Hispanic Chamber of Commerce, the Asian-American Chamber of Commerce of Greater Philadelphia, and the Greater Northeast Philadelphia Chamber of Commerce.
Our five Chambers represent more than 7,000 businesses of all sizes in Philadelphia and the surrounding area, in our shared missions to help our members grow their businesses and create jobs in our city and region. Today, we speak with one, united voice on the important topic of business taxes in Philadelphia.
First, we commend Councilman Green, Councilwoman Quinones Sanchez, Councilman Henon, and all of Council for their work over the past several years on the important issues surrounding business taxes and tax policy in Philadelphia. When Council introduced legislation adopting single sales factor apportionment, we supported this reform, to help simplify Business Privilege tax payments and collections, and increase the city’s ability to attract and retain business investment in jobs and facilities. When Council exempted all businesses from gross receipts and net income taxes on their first $100,000 of receipts, our Chambers supported this reform as well. Both of these pieces of legislation – approved by Council and signed by Mayor Nutter – encouraged and assisted businesses in Philadelphia to remain here, to grow, and to create jobs.
Second, we reiterate our position today to encourage Council to enact comprehensive tax reform for Philadelphia. Over the past four budget cycles, fiscal pressures caused by the recession led the administration to put on hold its program of gradual, incremental reductions in the city’s wage tax and business taxes. In addition, pressures caused by increased demand for city services, rising pension obligations, and a growing deficit at the Philadelphia School District led Council and the mayor to increase city taxes by $275 Million – a serious disincentive to jobs creation and economic competitiveness for every business in our city.
We restate our support for the Philadelphia Tax Reform Commission’s recommendation of 2003 – to gradually eliminate both sides of the BPT (now known as BIRT). It is worth quoting the Commission’s recommendation:
“Elimination of the Business Privilege Tax promotes tax system competitiveness by attracting new business investment, retaining those businesses that are considered leaving, fostering business expansion, and creating more jobs. Simply put, other local jurisdictions do not tax businesses the way Philadelphia does.”
We support modernizing city government, because only when we work together to adjust the capacity of City Hall to fit our city’s needs for the 21st Century will we create the flexibility to reduce the wage and business taxes that are stifling Philadelphia’s economic competitiveness every day.
We have also lent our strong support to Council’s drive to embrace new ways to raise revenues to deliver services without raising taxes – such as the Council President’s push to allow advertising on city-owned property, and Council’s plan to sell vacant school buildings to generate millions of dollars for public education. These are both very good ideas.
Regarding the bill before us today, when Council first considered the proposals in Bill 130530 three years ago, Council and the public had data showing which sectors of the business community benefitted, which sectors were disadvantaged, and by how much. Based upon that data, the Greater Philadelphia Chamber of Commerce testified it could not support the legislation, as it was concerned about the effect of the bill creating winners and losers among different businesses and sectors of industry.
At this time, similar data has not been presented. Without new data from the city or an independent expert on the impact of this bill on different business sectors, we cannot offer a reasoned judgment on how we view the legislation. We understand, from conversations with the bill’s sponsors and the Nutter Administration, that a study of the economic impact of the bill on the different kinds of companies that do business in Philadelphia will be conducted over the next several months.
We welcome and support that study, and we ask that the Mayor and Council include the Chambers of Commerce represented here today as willing partners in that study. We all have member businesses that would like the opportunity to participate in the study and have their voices and interests heard.
We ask that Council consider refraining from taking any official action on this important legislation until the results of this study are known and made available to all stakeholders, so that we can take an informed, educated stance on the bill. It was not that long ago when this Council rightfully balked at moving forward with a new method of assessing property in Philadelphia – AVI – until it had all the relevant assessment data it needed to make the right decisions about that important reform. We respectfully urge similar caution here – until we all understand the data and the legislation’s impact on the business community.
We stand ready – with 7,000 concerned and interested stakeholders – and eager to be engaged in the important work of determining whether this legislation is the right path to improve the climate to create a business, to grow a business, and to create jobs in Philadelphia.