GPCC President Rob Wonderling testified in opposition today on City Council legislation 130161, which sets a U & O tax rate that is double the U & O rate set forth in legislation offered by the Nutter Administration.  Passage of bill 130161 would be the fifth tax increase in the last four years, totaling some $275 million.

Testimony of the Greater Philadelphia Chamber of Commerce

On City Council Bill 130161

May 17, 2013

Good morning Chairman Green, Councilwoman Quinones Sanchez, and members of the Finance Committee. I am Rob Wonderling, President & CEO of the Greater Philadelphia Chamber of Commerce (GPCC), and am here today to testify on Bill 130161, which offers an exemption from the Use & Occupancy tax for certain small city businesses, and also sets a U & O tax rate that is higher than the U & O rate set forth in legislation offered by the Nutter Administration.

Over the past few months, Council has proposed a series of measures to generate additional revenues for the City without raising taxes.  In February, Council introduced a measure to examine how the City collects delinquent property taxes – a total delinquency exceeding $500 Million. The Chamber testified in support of Council’s initiative – and supports Mayor Nutter’s efforts as well to invest resources to better collect delinquent taxes.

Council President Clarke has introduced a bill to create a new Chief Revenue Generation Officer for Philadelphia, to seek innovations to raise revenues for the city – without raising taxes. The Chamber supports this idea – as well as the mayor’s appointment of Tom Knudsen to a new post, chief revenue collections officer, to coordinate all city efforts to collect delinquent taxes owed the city.

The Chamber also testified this spring in support of the Council President’s proposal to establish a comprehensive plan for advertising on city property – to generate millions of dollars in new city revenues – again, without raising taxes.

These proposals are all worth supporting on their merits. They also earned our support given the recent, unfortunate trends that have seen City Hall approve tax increases totaling $275 Million over the past four years.[1]

The sales tax increase, a series of property tax increases, a parking tax increase, and last year’s 19 percent increase in the Use & Occupancy tax to help the Philadelphia School District have created a chilling economic effect and additional costs for every business, small, medium-sized and large, that are the generators of hundreds of thousands of jobs for our citizens, the lifeblood of our city.

The Chamber also supports public education in Philadelphia, as one of our highest priority goals.  The Chamber just began our 9th year of operating Read to Me, a highly successful program aimed to encouraging early literacy among the youngest children in Philadelphia public schools. Working with the School District, Read to Me matches up business executives who donate to our Foundation, and volunteer their time to read to more than 3,000 children in over 30 Philadelphia schools. These donations help us purchase books and materials to fund and fill libraries in every one of these schools.

We are full, vigorous participants in the mayor’s 10,000 Summer Jobs program, and the Chamber regularly helps to create, among our members, more than 1,000 paying summer internships for the young men and women in our city, exposing them to the real world, teaching them valuable career skills.

As the Chamber’s chief executive, I was privileged to serve on the search committee that led to the School Reform Commission’s selection of Dr. William Hite as the School District’s new Superintendent. We strongly support Dr. Hite.

The Chamber collectively and myself individually have worked closely with the new leadership of the School Reform Commission, under Chairman Pedro Ramos, to help the District secure approvals for a $300 Million financing last year as the SRC did everything possible to reduce its large deficit to manageable levels.

There is nothing more important than giving every child in Philadelphia a quality education, and helping them achieve their fullest, God-given potential to be productive citizens.

However, the Chamber also has as its core mission advocating for more than 5,000 member businesses from throughout the Greater Philadelphia region – including over 2,500 members from here in Philadelphia. The majority of our members are small businesses, working hard every day to meet payrolls, grow their businesses, and contribute to a more vibrant economy in our city.

When every spring brings another tax increase, whether it’s from the property tax, the Use & Occupancy tax, or another tax, it sends a signal to these job creators that our city may not be the most conducive place to create jobs and continue growing their businesses. The signal it sends is the absence of economic opportunity.

And when a narrow slice of our citizenry – office building tenants – are asked for the second consecutive year to shoulder the burden for a broad-based public need – adequate funding for public education – we cannot support that. We do support the exemption in Bill 130161, as narrowly tailored to help small businesses in neighborhoods impacted by higher AVI assessments. But we cannot and do not support the higher Use & Occupancy tax rate as proposed. We remain open to discussions as to whether small businesses located in larger buildings downtown should receive a exemption similar to the one proposed in the legislation.

When Mayor Nutter introduced a series of measures yesterday to generate $95 Million in new revenues for the schools, he specifically noted that both residential property owners, commercial property owners, and business taxpayers have paid through a series of tax increases in recent years to help the schools, and that it was the wrong direction to take again this year. We concur.

We stand ready to assist this Council, the mayor, and the Philadelphia School District – as we have already done on countless occasions – to help gain support from Harrisburg to ensure our children receive a quality education in our schools.

Thank you for the opportunity to testify. We look forward to working with you on these issues, and I’d be happy to answer any questions you may have.


[1] Pennsylvania Intergovernmental Cooperation Authority (PICA).