Submitted by: Stanley P. Jaskiewicz, Esquire

Good lending depends on checklists.  The bankers have to review the due diligence, and the borrower’s financials, business and ratios.  The borrower must formally approve the loans, and the bank’s liens must be properly created and recorded.  “Safety in lending” starts with simply making sure that everything on the checklist has been done. 

But what if the checklist itself is wrong?  Unfortunately, that could easily happen if the borrower has critical IP assets, which often aren’t on a balance sheet or typical checklist.

A recent case suggests that the “IP checklist” may still be missing from lenders’ form documents.  This is a particular concern today, since intellectual property rights, such as a domain name, and trademarks and copyrights, can far outweigh the tangible assets in value.

Consider a traditional real estate loan – where rights to the business name were held separately by the business’s owner.  Unfortunately, the lender’s “standard form” and checklist did not lock up intellectual property, and the loan officer did not have enough experience to realize that he should ask counsel about rights to the borrower’s name.  As a result, after foreclosure the lender could not sell the property with the name under which it had been operated.

Once a lender recognizes the importance of thinking about IP assets just as it does about inventory, receivables, or real estate, it must look at its collateral base from a “backward” perspective, to decide whether it would be sufficient for the foreclosure purchaser.  Just as trademarks have no legal existence apart from the goodwill of the business associated with them, IP assets often do not have any intrinsic value.

Instead, they must be valued in conjunction with that business.  IP assets can increase the collateral value of the tangible assets, if they can be sold as a package following foreclosure.

Of course, once a lender or buyer understands that intellectual property rights are a critical asset in a deal, it still must create legal documents to work with them.  As in the real estate loan, the language in traditional form lending documents did not reach assets necessary to operate the property under its long standing name. 

Beyond simply making sure that IP is, in fact, “in the deal,” those whose deals involve IP collateral should think about other considerations not typically found in business loans:

  • The risk of loss of control of the property and rights.  While an artist or designer may have specific views about how a work should be marketed, a firm seeking to recover a loan may want to pursue a “monetization” plan that focuses more on quick payment, than on quality control. 
  • The borrower’s domain names.  Just as in taking real estate as collateral, the borrower’s domain name and related assets can be a valuable asset, even if the business conducted through them is not.  Lenders should take contractual control of the domain name, subject to the terms of a control agreement with the borrower.  (But the lender must be sure to file a renewal on time, to avoid having to “buy it back” from cybersquatters, who watch for expirations of active domain names.  Lenders may prefer the relatively nominal expense of multi-year registrations to avoid this risk.)
  • Formal transfer requirements.  A transfer of IP rights through the loan foreclosure process is not enough, just as a sheriff’s deed must be recorded to reflect a foreclosure sale of real estate.  Follow up filings may be needed in the Copyright Office or with the Patent and Trademark Office.  Lenders’ counsel should anticipate future needs to transfer collateral after a default through documents signed at a loan closing, such as a power of attorney. 
  • Works for Hire.  If the collateral includes copyrights, the borrower should have (and pledge to the lender) assignable rights from everyone involved in their creation.  The “work made for hire” rules (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Work_for_hire) may require getting rights from many persons in the chain of creation – or a strong indemnification from the borrower, should anyone later claim infringement by the foreclosure purchaser.

Perhaps the most important “unusual” concern with IP collateral is recognizing that it can change regularly. 

Just as I have urged lenders and their counsel to review their checklists to account for the importance of IP assets in today’s economy, I also urge them to periodically update the checklists themselves, since technology law is itself in constant flux.  Developments in the law or technology may make today’s good checklist not only obsolete, but simply wrong, much more quickly than loan officers not familiar with the economy may expect. 

Lenders must think critically about what legal IP rights they need when a loan is first made, not just when they foreclose.

Copyright 2011 Stanley P. Jaskiewicz, Esquire